César Quevedo
Bachelor of Chemical Sciences
Assistant Director of the Insurance and Social Protection department
Ana Belén Herrero
Bachelor of Actuarial and Financial Sciences and of Business Management and Administration
Coordinator of the project «Insurance for Everyone»
FUNDACIÓN MAPFRE
Madrid - Spain

^{* «Seguros para todos»}

Introduction to financial education

Concern by international bodies, governments, supervisors and regulators regarding the financial education or literacy of our society has noticeably increased in recent years, following -perhaps lagging somewhat behind the development of the financial markets and the social and demographic changes of the last two decades. The general consensus among experts is that society’s knowledge on the various savings, investment and financing products available has not matched the consumption or use of these products. This has meant that a large portion of society has managed their personal finances with little or no prior understanding of what they were committing themselves to; this, they say, has lead to debt and other similar problems that are difficult to handle.

The need for citizens to be better informed has become even more evident during the financial crisis, when the poor standard of general knowledge came to light at precisely the worst moment. Some may think that only professional investors need such expertise, but the truth is that it affects all families, at all levels of society, because informed decision-making is essential for guaranteeing our health, our home(s) and our current and future living conditions. The problem is two-fold: first, people do not have sufficient knowledge; second, they are being offered a vast range of financial services and products that have become increasingly complex and technical over time.

Society’s knowledge on the various savings, investment and financing products available has not matched the consumption or use of these products. This has meant that a large portion of society has managed their personal finances with little or no prior understanding

The world’s financial environment is volatile and ever-changing, and the risk factors that shape it are diverse, from purely financial to political, cultural, social and demographic. The following key parameters have influenced recent developments: rising per-capita income and associated higher savings capacity; the huge range of financial products available on the market; a steady increase in the level of indebtedness; longer life expectancy; job insecurity; changes in the benefits of public health systems, social benefits and pensions; changes in tax legislation; deregulation; the increase in electronic transactions and decrease in the use of paper money, to name but a few.

Given all of the above, properly administering financial resources requires more knowledge and skills than it used to. Ultimately, for governments, investing in financial literacy and training is a way of cultivating social well-being and ensuring the future growth of a country.

The role of insurance

Against this backdrop, insurance is a key financial product that we would do well to understand, as it is one of the most important guarantees for maintaining our basic personal needs and, in many cases, it is the principal repository of family savings. A correct understanding of the benefits, capacity and limitations of insurance policies is a key security factor in people’s lives and, as such, education regarding insurance must play a major role in the education of our citizens. However, there are currently very few initiatives aimed at promoting a culture of insurance beyond those that are produced merely for commercial purposes.

Background of financial education

The history of modern financial education began in the United States in the early 90s, with the first analyses pertaining to savings in homes. Although these studies were focused on the efficiency of tax incentives for saving, they seemed to show a certain correlation between low rates of saving and low financial literacy. Other studies were also performed to establish the effects of financial education in schools on individual savings and to see what long-term changes there were in consumer behaviour; it was found that those persons who had received education displayed higher savings rates and accumulated more wealth as adults. Subsequently, in the first decade of this century, research was continued in Europe and other industrialised countries on people’s financial behaviour (planning and saving for retirement, types of investments used, level of wealth accumulation, level of indebtedness) and their financial knowledge, reaching the same general conclusions: the correlation between a person’s financial education and the quality of their savings and investment decisions was clearly established.

A correct understanding of the benefits, capacity and limitations of insurance policies is a key security factor in people’s lives and, as such, education regarding insurance must play a major role in the education of our citizens

Regarding the activity of international or supranational bodies, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) has played an important role. A significant milestone was undoubtedly the presentation in 2005 of its study «Improving Financial Literacy. Analysis of Issues and Policies» (see 1 in References) that showed the results of analyses on consumers’ financial literacy and the effects of the programmes pertaining to this issue in 15 countries. It also provided the first broad definition of financial education (Text 1). In general, these studies all came to similar conclusions, notably that financial literacy was quite low, and that consumers generally lacked knowledge of the risks they assumed and engaged in inadequate long-term financial planning. It also pointed out that the lower one’s socio-economic status, the greater one’s lack of financial literacy was likely to be.

Based on the results of this study and also in 2005, the OECD Council published a resolution (see 2 in References) in which it invited the Member States to implement policies that would promote financial education, designing programmes aimed at and adapted to all segments of the population. The resolution includes the general principles and good practices for its publication and application by governments and institutions.

Since then, many studies, surveys and programmes have been published on the issue, many of them with the financial crisis as a backdrop; in turn, the governments of developed countries have followed the OECD indications and have mostly designed national strategies and plans for financial education. Many companies and private organisations have also implemented their own initiatives.

Financial Education Plan, Spain

The National Securities Market Commission (CNMV) and the Banco de España (BdE), the country’s most senior financial supervisors, undertook in May 2008 to draft, publish and develop the «Financial Education Plan» and the principal aim was to contribute to the improvement of citizens’ financial literacy

Focusing on the case of Spain, the National Securities Market Commission (CNMV) and the Banco de España (BdE), the country’s most senior financial supervisors, undertook in May 2008 to draft, publish and develop the «Financial Education Plan» (see 3, 4 in References) under the principles and recommendations of the OECD, the principal aim of which was to «contribute to the improvement of citizens’ financial literacy». Subsequently, the General Directorate for Insurance and Pension Funds, Spain’s insurance regulator, joined the Financial Education Plan along with many other public and private companies and associations.

Within the Plan, a financial education website was designed as the main channel for information and training: «Finance for Everyone» (www.finanzasparatodos.es). Other information and training activities were also carried out. This four-year plan 2008-2012 was extended to the period 2013-2017. Table 1 shows the general guidelines of the first Plan.

The project «Insurance for Everyone», by FUNDACIÓN MAPFRE

Background

Within the general context described above, in 2011 FUNDACIÓN MAPFRE set itself a new goal of contributing towards improving citizens’ insurance literacy; this goal aligns perfectly with the objectives of the foundation. In order to accomplish this project as effectively as possible, it was deemed necessary to carry out a study (see 5 in References) that would gather information on the matter and identify the educational requirements regarding insurance in Spain. (Text 3)

Based on this, the project «Insurance for Everyone» was born in 2012, with the aim of improving social perception of insurance through knowledge of insurance culture, its principles and basic tenets. Given that its approach dovetailed well with the initiatives of the Financial Education Plan, the FUNDACIÓN MAPFRE signed a collaboration agreement with the BdE and the CNMV to develop insurance-related content.

Philosophy and aims of «Insurance for Everyone»

«Insurance for Everyone» aspires to help citizens understand the basics of insurance and by extension, how the insurance sector works. Given that this is a broad aspiration and the profiles of the stakeholder groups vary widely, the guiding principles have been defined as follows:

• Universality: The principles that govern financial and insurance education are universal and therefore, the content of the project tends towards generality. However, the needs of the various social groups and the specific realities of the countries and geographical areas involved are taken into consideration.
• Aimed at non-experts: The target audience is not expert in insurance. Simple language that strikes a balance between jargon and technical precision is preferred.
• Easily accessible: Access to information must be easy, free and universal, so that the content can be consulted regardless of the manner in which it is accessed. Visibility through different media is required to achieve this, both on the internet (www.segurosparatodos.org) and by traditional means, usually print.
• Possibility of interaction: This is an essential factor if a society is genuinely interested in stating its opinion on the products and services that are marketed or offered. Along these lines, the informative strategy is designed for the interaction to be real and bi-directional, based on active listening.

Scope of the project

«Insurance for Everyone» aspires to help citizens understand the basics of insurance and how the insurance sector works. It is aimed at all citizens in a variety of different social groups

Given its essence and origin, «Insurance for Everyone» is aimed at all citizens in a variety of different social groups. Geographically, the Foundation focuses the bulk of its activity on the countries in which it has an institutional presence.

Following the principles of the OECD, education in matters of insurance must be provided to a broad target audience. However, demographic groups with similar features are established, depending either on the training requirements presented, or on the access channels that are considered most effective. Table 2 shows the different population groups and the actions planned for each of them.

Content

The website presents nuts-and-bolts information on insurance. It also addresses the following specific issues: fraud and the harm it causes to society as a whole; the rights and obligations of the insured; the role of mediation, etc. The website also contains a glossary where the essential terminology is explained in simple words. A consultancy service with experts is also available to discuss specific insurance questions; this is explicitly neutral and non-commercial.

The importance of interaction and social media

In order to find out first-hand where society is lacking and has difficulties regarding insurance, it is essential to use the new technologies and tools that enable interaction with users. This will allow us to design materials that relate to the issues that arouse the most interest. «Insurance for Everyone» was not conceived only as a place to store data on a website; it is a set of initiatives featuring different media that seeks to promote this interaction so that the users themselves can decide on part of the content and can openly express their expectations and needs.

Social media are very useful tools for transmitting this message to society; the most common platforms -Facebook, Twitter and Youtube- are leveraged for this purpose.

• Facebook is the main channel for promoting the content of «Insurance for Everyone»; the specific aim is to generate a community that will provide new ideas and actions, and will serve as a channel for spreading insurance literacy.
• Twitter cultivates relationships with experts with an online presence; these individuals can «vet» content and endow it with further reliability.
• Youtube is used in its double role as a repository for the project’s audiovisual content and as a global medium that takes advantage of the viral nature of the Internet.

Teaching: a key element in developing the project

Teaching is one of the basic pillars of «Insurance for Everyone»; its ultimate goal is to be practical, so that it can help in real-life situations.

There are two strands of teaching activities:

• Basic teaching for the general public: Simple courses that focus on single insurance issues, e.g. types of insurance, fraud, protecting the insured person, purchasing insurance, making a claim.
• Training for teachers: It is only possible for the population to receive information on insurance from an early age if teachers are suitably prepared for this job; «Insurance for Everyone» will provide the necessary training and resources so that teachers can confidently provide education on insurance for their students.

This training also involves other related groups: Social workers and other personnel who work with seniors or disabled persons, employees of financial and insurance companies. To this end, training materials and tools will be created to reinforce the content currently available on education syllabuses.

The future

«Insurance for Everyone» is just the beginning and the project will only bear fruit in the medium to long term. Meanwhile, we must analyse the effectiveness of all of the activities and quantify their true impact both on the population at large and on specific groups. Doing so will enable us to calibrate future activities and guarantee the success of these educational programmes. Of course, any such initiative must continue to be aligned with institutional measures and plans in order to maximise mutual benefit.

References

• (1) OCDE. «Improving Financial Literacy. Analysis of Issues and Policies.» 2005.
  Available online at:
  http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/financeand-
  investment/improving-financialliteracy_9789264012578-en
• (2) «Recommendation on Principles and Good Practices for Financial Education and Awareness.» «Recommendation of the Council.» OCDE. July, 2005.
  Available online at:
  http://www.oecd.org/finance/financial-education/35108560.pdf
• (3, 4) CNMV (Spanish National Securities Market Commission) and Bank of Spain. «Plan de Educación Financiera 2008-2012» and «Plan de Educación Financiera 2013-2017.»
  Available online at:
  http://www.cnmv.es/Portal/Publicaciones/ PlanEducCNMV.aspx
• (5) FUNDACIÓN MAPFRE. «La percepción social del seguro en España.» 2012.
  Available online at:
  http://www.fundacionmapfre.org/fundacion/es_es/images/
  La-percepcion-social-del-seguro-en-espanya_tcm164-3796.pdf

Further references

• OCDE/INFE. «High level principles on national strategies for financial education.» 2012.
  Available online at:
  http://www.oecd.org/finance/financial-education/
  OECD_INFE_High_Level_Principles_National_ Strategies_Financial_Education_APEC.pdf
• ISPIERTO, A. y OLIVER, I. «La educación financiera y su relevancia en las decisiones económicas: evidencia e iniciativas.» CNMV’s quarterly bulletin. Quarter IV. 2011. CNMV, Madrid.
  Available online at:
  http://www.cnmv.es/DocPortal/Publicaciones/Boletin/Boletin_4_2011.pdf

 

subir